top of page

Meaning in the Mess: A Simple Exercise for Finding Opportunity in Life’s Obstacles

Writer: Bobby Jakucs, Psy.D.
Bobby Jakucs, Psy.D.
3 hours ago
8 min read

"An adventure is only an inconvenience rightly considered."

- G.K. Chesterton


Paint-splattered art table with acrylic paint bottles, palettes, and brushes, messy colorful studio scene.

This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you click and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no cost to you. These small earnings help fund the mission of the Take Courage Resilience Center and keep the lights on. Thank you for your support.


If you'd like future reflections delivered straight to your inbox—grounded in faith, inspired by classical wisdom, and informed by evidence-based psychology—subscribe here

I don’t know about you but I have never woken up and had the thought, “well I hope everything goes wrong today!” In fact usually I’m hoping for the opposite. But some days it seems like if it weren’t for Murphy’s Law there’d be no law at all.


The fact is, life is messy. Plans we make unravel. Setbacks occur. Things sometimes just don’t go our way.


In these situations, like a classic noir detective, our minds readily “cut to the chase” and see exactly what is wrong in a situation. Stories like The Mysterious Case of the Deleted Blog Draft quickly materialize and come into focus, bringing along a host of unpleasant feelings.


The mind is really good at finding suspects too. Casting blame on everything and everyone. Life often starts to feel like a noir film: dark, cold and somehow always raining (even in Los Angeles).


Now, to be fair, sometimes the mind has some good points. There are situations that are problematic, unfair and downright wrong. There may be very often legitimate concerns.


The problem is, when our attention is consumed entirely by the negative in a situation we can lose sight of other possibilities. Perhaps, hidden within these unpleasant experiences is something deeper.


In other words, what if there is more to a situation than the familiar story the mind tells us?


Chesterton once quipped, “An adventure is only an inconvenience rightly considered.” Case in point, Frodo was certainly inconvenienced by Gandalf giving him the one ring. But if he was never inconvenienced, he’d never have left the Shire.


So, if you’re willing let’s be a little adventurous. Let’s take a step outside the Shire with one of my favorite exercises for discovering meaning in the mess.


Well, actually we’re going to take 10 steps.


Why Our Minds Get Stuck


Three men push a white GMC van stuck in muddy desert dirt road, with snowy mountains in the background.

Marcus Aurelius once said, “the universe is transformation, life is opinion.” He wasn’t wrong.


In psychology there is a well researched phenomenon called negativity bias. The human mind has a tendency to assign greater weight and attention to negative information. If you want proof, turn on any news station.


Our minds focus on the negative because evolutionarily it was adaptive. We are able to quickly notice potential threats. The problem is, our minds don’t know when to stop. We therefore, tend to hyper focus on the obstacles themselves, often missing the potential opportunities within the obstacle.


In consciously reflecting upon and reevaluating a situation, rather than immediately buying the first story the mind tells us, we can more readily respond to the situation according to our values, even with difficult emotions present. In research terms this is one aspect of cognitive reappraisal and is a hallmark of resiliency.


Notably, this does not mean every negative thought is false. It certainly does not mean our suffering is imaginary. What it does mean is that we have a capacity to respond to a given situation - we can find a meaning.


Viktor Frankl, the psychiatrist and Holocaust survivor, recognized that in the hell of a Nazi concentration camp, individuals stripped of all freedom still retained what he called, “the last of the human freedoms”: some capacity, even internally by the attitude one adopts, to take a courageous stance towards life’s blows.


He came to develop the concept tragic optimism. As is evident by the phrasing, tragic optimism does not negate tragedy, loss, or disappointment. It fully accepts the pain of a difficult situation.


However, it recognizes that suffering does not get the last word. Like a candle in a dark night, it remains defiant. Often, not because it is particularly bright, but simply because it refuses to stop burning.


The Ten Positive Things Exercise


Close-up of a mossy stone wall with a faded black number 10 painted on it.

Some individuals may be born with an inherent “sunny” disposition. However, tragic optimism  is not a disposition, rather it is a conscious stance towards life. One that embraces the givens of life - guilt, suffering and death - while recognizing meaning can still be found within these painful realities.


One powerful tool for cultivating an openness to that possibility is called 10 Positive Things, from Alex Pattakos and Elaine Dundon’s book Prisoners of Our Thoughts. Their work is deeply reflective of Frankl’s Logotherapy. Pattakos in fact studied under Frankl.


Through regular practice, we can learn to loosen our attachment to a single interpretation of an experience. Doing so can create space to see not just obstacles and setbacks (which may be very real) but potentials and possibilities. It’s an exercise I both regularly practice and teach.


  1. Identify a Difficult Situation. Choose a particular situation causing stress, disappointment, frustration or discouragement.

  2. Acknowledge What’s Difficult. Don’t minimize the problem or pretend it’s not a problem. Allow whatever is present to be present.

  3. Write Out 10 Positive Things that are, or could potentially be, associated with the situation. Brainstorm and be creative. Stretch your imagination. Don’t immediately reject any idea simply because of its unlikelihood. Importantly list out not just positive things that may happen but negative things that may not happen (which is also a positive). Also ask yourself, “are there any opportunities to practice a virtue here?”

  4. Review Your List. Once you have your list review it and reflect: which possibilities offer a new perspective, reveal an opportunity or point toward something meaningful.

  5. Choose a Response. Ask yourself, “What is one small action I can take that reflects my values?”


Here’s an example of one I recently did. I’m an avid surfer. It’s one of the greatest joys in my life. After a really long week I couldn’t wait to get in the water. When that long-awaited day arrived I woke up to find it was pouring rain outside. In Los Angeles, that means sewage, run off and a whole lot of nasty germs that end up hitching a ride on any surfer who opts to paddle out.


I’ll admit, I was in surf lingo, “bummed out.” My mind did what minds do in such situations and reflected upon all the negative aspects of that situation. Realizing what my mind was doing, I put pen to paper and wrote out 10 positive things about my long awaited plans falling through:


  1. This can be an opportunity to practice

  2. I can spend the time cleaning out the garage

  3. I can find an alternative workout for today

  4. Perhaps I just avoided some injury

  5. I now have more time with the kids

  6. I don’t need to rush out and can enjoy my cup of coffee (the kids weren’t up yet)

  7. I have a few extra minutes to read today

  8. This could be an opportunity to practice gratitude for all the times I’ve been able to surf

  9. I can offer this disappointment up for the Souls in Purgatory

  10. I can use this for my next blog post!


Note: nothing about my external situation changed. I did not surf. My disappointment was real. But, alongside that disappointment I uncovered several opportunities which were just as real - if I was willing to take the next step.


This is a skill that requires practice. It’s also best to start small with manageable stressors rather than tackling bigger challenges, setbacks or traumas.


Pattakos describes a powerful story of teaching this exercise to a group of inmates. Many were serving lengthy sentences. Notably, some initially struggled to find anything positive in their experience.


In time many were able to develop a new appreciation for relationships and responsibility. Some reflected on the value of life and freedom, or the opportunity to now be role models.


Their witness was profound. Despite being confined in a literal prison, they found meaning in the mess.


From Obstacles to Opportunities: The Freedom to Respond


Friends outdoors push a giant tire obstacle in a park, smiling, while one person films on a phone.

The Stoics frequently reflected that experiencing a setback and being defeated by it are two different things. In Meditations, Marcus Aurelius writes, “Not that this is a misfortune, but that to bear it nobly is good fortune.” Difficult circumstances need not prevent us from acting with justice, love, and courage.


The key is recognizing that the opportunity does not lie in the obstacle itself, but rather how we respond to it. Frankl illuminates this juxtaposition in Man’s Search for Meaning:


“Ultimately, man should not ask what the meaning of his life is, but rather must recognize that it is he who is asked. In a word, each man is questioned by life; and he can only answer to life by answering for his own life; to life he can only respond by being responsible.”


Make no mistake, each obstacle, setback, and loss presents real challenge. But they also present us with a question that if we are not careful, will go unanswered. In doing so, we often add to the pain caused by a situation.


In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy we work toward cultivating psychological flexibility, making room for uncomfortable internal experiences so we can act according to our values. In other words, when we loosen our attachment to the first negative interpretation of an event -  even if there is truth in it - we can more readily respond from a place of intention.


The interesting thing is, in generating 10 Positive Things, we may find one meaningful path forward.


Finding Meaning Does Not Require Denial


There’s an important distinction to reiterate.


In practicing 10 Positive Things, or similar exercises, we are not trying to erase a negative situation.  Insisting on positive thinking while denying the reality of our suffering is not resilience. It can become another way of avoiding the very experiences we need to acknowledge.


This unhelpful attitude is termed toxic positivity and for good reason. Toxic positivity is the antithesis of tragic optimism.


Some losses are genuinely tragic, unjust and irreparable. We need not force gratitude where there is none, nor try to delete a painful emotion (it’s impossible). Frankl himself cautioned that optimism should never be forced.


We are also not trying to find a lesson in every tragedy. Sometimes there are none to glean. Similarly, there are real boundaries to our freedom. Our painful pasts are real and often have tangible impact on our present circumstances.


The point is, while we many not be in a literal prison, our lives do sometimes have real prison bars. And despite that, there remains an invitation. Not to deny that our prison bars exist. Rather to simply ask, “What is possible if I don’t grip them so tightly?”



Finding Meaning in the Mess


There’s a beautiful verse in a hymn sung on Holy Saturday, “Oh happy fault that earned so great, so glorious a Redeemer!” It resounds one of the many paradoxes of the Christian faith. In the tragedy that was our Fall, God brought about the incomparable good of redemption through Christ.


Part of growth in the spiritual life is recognizing that two seemingly opposing truths can coexist.  Part of cultivating psychological flexibility is recognizing that as well.


So perhaps, take five minutes this week and practice this exercise. Start with something that seems manageable. Don’t worry about producing 10 brilliant insights. Some of them may be ridiculous.


That’s ok.


Once you write them out, simply notice whether the exercise opens possibilities you had not previously considered.


Then ask yourself, “what good might I be able to pursue here?”


It’s likely the situation that you reflected on will not have changed. Life will no doubt be asking you the same question it was five minutes ago.


But, maybe now you can give an answer.




Disclaimer
This post is for informational and inspirational purposes only and does not constitute medical or psychological advice. The content provided here is not a substitute for professional care, diagnosis or treatment. Reading this blog, subscribing to updates or engaging with its content does not establish a therapist-client relationship. Please consult a licensed healthcare professional for personal support.
Logo for Take Courage Resilience Center, Catholic therapist and resilience focused blog and course site
bottom of page